**Heavy Metals in Protein Powders and Ready-to-Drink Products: What Consumers Need to Know**
Powder and ready-to-drink protein sales have exploded, reaching over US$32 billion globally from 2024 to 2025. Increasingly, consumers are using these protein sources daily. However, a new study by Consumer Reports, published on October 14, 2025, raises concerns about dangerously high levels of lead and other heavy metals such as cadmium and arsenic in some protein products.
As a clinical pharmacologist who has evaluated heavy metal content in baby food, calcium supplements, and kratom products, I understand that lead and other heavy metals occur naturally in soil and water, making zero-level exposure practically impossible. It’s important to note that the level of lead exposure Consumer Reports deems safe is significantly lower than the limits set by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA). Still, the study highlights that a few products deliver a concerningly high dose of heavy metals per serving.
### How Consumer Reports Conducted the Study
The study assessed 23 powder and ready-to-drink protein products from popular brands, sending three samples of each product to an independent commercial laboratory for testing.
Consumer Reports considers anything over 0.5 micrograms of lead per day from any single source to be above recommended maximum levels. This threshold is based on guidelines from the California Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment, which favors very conservative exposure limits designed to minimize cancer risks or fetal harm. This is much stricter than the FDA’s safety standard for lead exposure in drugs and supplements.
According to the FDA:
– The maximum safe lead exposure from any single dietary supplement is 5 micrograms per day – ten times higher than Consumer Reports’ limit.
– The total allowable daily lead intake from all sources (food, drugs, supplements) is called the Interim Reference Level (IRL).
– For people who could become pregnant, the IRL is 8.8 micrograms per day.
– For children, the IRL is 2.2 micrograms per day.
– For everyone else, the IRL is set at 12.5 micrograms per day.
Because every food, drug, and supplement containing lead contributes to total daily exposure, it’s crucial to keep levels below these IRLs.
### Key Findings from the Consumer Reports Study
– **16 out of 23 products** tested exceeded the 0.5 micrograms lead limit per serving that Consumer Reports considers safe.
– **4 products** exceeded 2.2 micrograms of lead, which is the FDA’s maximum total daily amount for children.
– **2 products** contained 72% and 88%, respectively, of the allowable daily lead intake for pregnant women according to FDA standards.
– Regarding other heavy metals, **2 products** exceeded Consumer Reports’ safety limit for cadmium (4.1 micrograms per day), and **1 product** exceeded the recommended arsenic limit (7 micrograms per day).
Consumer Reports’ cadmium and arsenic safety thresholds closely align with FDA limits — 5 micrograms per day for cadmium and 15 micrograms per day for arsenic per single product.
An important pattern emerged: plant-derived protein products contained **nine times more lead** than dairy-based proteins like whey, and **twice as much** as beef-based protein.
### Where Are These Heavy Metals Coming From?
Heavy metals such as lead, cadmium, and arsenic often originate from environmental sources, including:
– **Volcanic rock and magma:** When volcanic rock erodes, heavy metals contaminate local soil and water supplies.
– **Certain crops:** Some plants are highly efficient at absorbing heavy metals from soil, concentrating these toxins in the parts we consume.
– **Fossil fuels:** Burning fossil fuels releases heavy metals into the air, which settle into soil and water.
– **Agricultural chemicals:** Some fertilizers, herbicides, and pesticides contain heavy metals, contributing to contamination.
High levels of heavy metals have been found in various foods and supplements, including plant-based protein powders, spices like cinnamon, dark chocolate, root vegetables (carrots, sweet potatoes), rice, legumes (pea pods), and many herbal supplements.
### Should Consumers Be Concerned? What Can You Do?
Occasionally exceeding the recommended daily levels of heavy metals is unlikely to cause immediate health problems. However, repeated, heavy exposure can have serious consequences. Accumulation of heavy metals in the blood may:
– Delay or impair cognitive function,
– Damage nerves,
– Soften bones,
– Raise blood pressure, increasing stroke and heart attack risk,
– Increase cancer risk over time.
It’s reassuring that all products Consumer Reports flagged contained lead levels significantly below the FDA’s maximum daily exposure levels.
To reduce exposure:
– Prefer **dairy- or animal-based protein products**, which generally tend to have lower heavy metal contamination than plant-based alternatives.
– Note that some plant-based protein products tested did not have high heavy metal levels, highlighting variability.
– Understand that heavy metal contamination varies widely in the environment. Results from the Consumer Reports study are a snapshot and may not reflect all batches if manufacturers change raw ingredient sources.
– For products with high heavy metal levels, **limiting consumption to occasional use rather than daily intake** can reduce risk.
– Studies suggest that **organic plant-based products** typically have lower heavy metal content compared to conventionally farmed ones.
– Be mindful of **serving sizes**, as the study measured heavy metal content per serving. Avoid sharply increasing daily protein consumption that could raise exposure.
### The Bottom Line
The significant variation in lead levels across protein products underscores the need for manufacturers to strengthen product testing and adopt better manufacturing practices. Consumers should stay informed, choose products wisely, and moderate intake to minimize heavy metal exposure while benefiting from protein supplementation.
—
*Sources: Consumer Reports study (October 14, 2025), FDA guidelines, California Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment*
https://knowridge.com/2025/10/protein-powders-and-shakes-contain-high-amounts-of-lead-new-report-says/